Showing posts with label Bank of England. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Bank of England. Show all posts

Wednesday, March 19, 2014

Wednesday, March 19, 2014 - Behind the Curtain of the Mysterious Central Bankers

Behind the Curtain of the Mysterious Central Bankers
by Sinclair Noe

DOW – 114 = 16,222
SPX – 11 = 1860
NAS – 25 = 4307
10 YR YLD + .09 = 2.77%
OIL + .67 = 100.37
GOLD – 24.90 = 1331.60
SILV - .20 = 20.71

Sometimes the stock market is a grand mystery, a riddle wrapped in a mystery inside an enigma. Sometimes the stock market is simple. Wall Street loves it when the Federal Reserve is throwing bags of money out of the helicopter that hovers over Wall Street. The traders get a little nervous when it looks like the free money might stop raining down on them. That doesn’t mean the Fed is stopping throwing money at Wall Street, just that traders are nervous.

Today, the Fed FOMC wrapped up a two day meeting; they issued a statement; then Chairwoman Janet Yellen delivered a prepared statement; then she answered questions.

The Fed statement indicated the Fed could and likely would continue with its low interest rate policy even after they reach their goals of full employment and 2% inflation. The central bank proceeded with its well-telegraphed reductions to its massive bond-buying stimulus, announcing it would cut its monthly purchases of Treasuries and mortgage-backed securities to $55 billion from $65 billion per month.

I will now attempt to translate the Fed statement from Fedspeak to English. The statement said: the labor market is getting better but unemployment is still too high, household and business spending is decent but the housing market is weak, the politicians in Washington keep messing up the economy but they haven’t been adding on new mistakes lately so we should be able to work around them, inflation is too low and that might cause problems, even as they cut purchases to $25 billion a month in mortgage backed securities and $30 billion a month in Treasuries – that is still a heck of a lot of paper they are buying, the Fed analysts will keep an eye on economic conditions and at some point they will raise rates but not today and not based on a 6.5% target for unemployment, and the analysts think the economy is better than the  public thinks, and the only reason the economy is so bad is because the weather has just been horrible this winter.

Then, Janet Yellen held a press conference. Back in December the Fed forecasts called for unemployment falling to between 5.8% and 6.1% by the fourth quarter of 2015. The new forecasts show Fed officials see unemployment dropping slightly faster, to between 5.6% and 5.9% by the end of 2015. So, that ratchets up forward guidance on rates. Fed officials see slightly sharper increases than they did in December, with rates ending 2015 at 1% and ending 2016 at 2.25%, according to the median of forecasts. In December, Fed officials expected short-term rates to be just 1.75% by the end of 2016. Of course, that’s all dependent on economic data over the next year or more, and we could have another unexpected snowstorm or 2 or 20, but it was enough to make Wall Street traders nervous that the Federal Reserve won’t always provide a super low interest rate subsidy to the bankers.

The nervousness only grew as Yellen entered the Question and Answer phase of the press conference. She was asked how long the Fed would wait after the tapering ends before it begins to raise interest rates. She answered: “So the language that we used in the statement is ‘considerable period.’ So I, you know, this is the kind of term it’s hard to define. But, you know, probably means something on the order of around six months, that type of thing.”

So, let’s do the math. The Fed continues to taper asset purchases by $10 billion a month; announcing incremental cuts at each of the next 6 FOMC meetings; so maybe around October, they finish the buying; then 6 months pass and now we’re looking at April 2015, which is more or less when everybody knew the Fed might start to consider raising rates, if everything goes according to plan…, and we don’t have any more surprise snow storms.

And that is a big change for trying to figure out when the Fed will raise rates. It’s no more quantitative easing, based on a hard, quantitative number like 6.5% unemployment rate. Now the Wall Street traders actually have to look at the economy and try to guess the qualitative factors. Translation: the Fed is looking at when the economy improves, and the economy comprises a giant number of measures and statistics. If Wall Street wants Cliffs Notes, it will have to look elsewhere.

Interest rates matter to the Wall Street traders because it determines the profits for the Wall Street banks that trade Treasuries and mortgages and such, and they want the data spoon fed, kind of like the kid taking a test with an open book.

Part of the problem with the old 6.5% rule was that the unemployment rate didn’t do a good job of measuring the real employment picture; the unemployment rate was dropping, getting close to the 6.5% target, but that’s because more people were dropping out of the workforce. The unemployment rate only measures people who are still in the workforce and can’t find jobs; it ignores those who have given up.

Yellen just ended the “open book” testing. No longer will the Fed promise to raise interest rates at 6.5% unemployment. Instead, the Fed will raise interest rates when the economy is strong enough to justify it. Wall Street will have to actually pay more attention to the strength of the economy than they pay to filling out their basketball brackets.

Telling Wall Street traders to think is tricky business; they don’t think, they trade. The Fed, under Yellen, wants to keep market expectations aligned with their own forecasts. If traders start to price in earlier rate hikes, the result would be tighter financial conditions that could deter the very investment and hiring that the Fed wants to promote.

The only thing traders heard today was “around six months”. Did Yellen mean to be that specific? No, the Fed has always loosely defined “considerable period” as about half a year. It’s supposed to be a little vague. She probably didn’t intend to give any hints about timing beyond what the “dot plot” said. No Fed chair is going to confidently tell markets that it’s going to raise rates in 14 months. But now that she’s leading the Fed, the markets will react to what she said, not what she means. And this is where it gets interesting. Will Yellen and her Fed colleagues try to “walk back” her statements, or will they leave them out there as they stand. It could be a defining moment in the early stages of the Yellen-led Fed.

Meanwhile, there are some new definitions in on central banks role in the process of printing money, and that came from the Bank of England a few days ago. In a paper called “Money Creation in the Modern Economy”  co-authored by 3 economists on behalf of the  Bank of England, they state that most common assumptions of how banking works are simply wrong, and the entire theoretical basis for austerity is wrong.

Consider the old, conventional view, which continues to be the basis of most of the debate on public policy and the framework for austerity. People put their money in banks. Banks then lend that money out at interest – either to consumers, or to entrepreneurs willing to invest it in some profitable enterprise. True, the fractional reserve system does allow banks to lend out considerably more than they hold in reserve, and true, if savings don't suffice, private banks can seek to borrow more from the central bank.

The central bank can print as much money as it wishes. But it is also careful not to print too much. In fact, we are often told this is why independent central banks exist in the first place. If governments could print money themselves, they would surely put out too much of it, and the resulting inflation would throw the economy into chaos. Institutions such as the Bank of England or US Federal Reserve were created to carefully regulate the money supply to prevent inflation.

Under this old, conventional definition, money is a finite resource; there are limits. What the Bank of England admitted this week is that none of this is really true. To quote from its own initial summary: "Rather than banks receiving deposits when households save and then lending them out, bank lending creates deposits" … "In normal times, the central bank does not fix the amount of money in circulation, nor is central bank money 'multiplied up' into more loans and deposits."

In other words, everything we know is not just wrong – it's backwards. When banks make loans, they create money. This is because money is really just an IOU. The role of the central bank is to preside over a legal order that effectively grants banks the exclusive right to create IOUs of a certain kind, ones that the government will recognize as legal tender by its willingness to accept them in payment of taxes. There's really no limit on how much banks could create, provided they can find someone willing to borrow it.

What this means is that the real limit on the amount of money in circulation is not how much the central bank is willing to lend, but how much government, firms, and ordinary citizens, are willing to borrow. Government spending is the main driver in all this. So, there's no question of public spending "crowding out" private investment. It's exactly the opposite.


Some of us have known this for quite some time, but this was the first time a major central bank has admitted it. Why did they admit it? Probably because that whole austerity thing hasn’t been working out.

Thursday, January 9, 2014

Thursday, January 09, 2014 - A World Of Central Bankers

A World Of Central Bankers
by Sinclair Noe

DOW – 17 = 16,444
SPX + 0.64 = 1838
NAS – 9 = 4156
10 YR YLD - .03 = 2.96%
OIL - .67 = 91.66
GOLD + 1.80 = 1228.70
SILV + .02 = 19.65

If it's not one central bank, it's another. Today the European Central Bank and the Bank of England met to determine monetary policy. Back in November, the ECB cut interest rates to 0.25%, so there were no expectations of further rate cuts in today's meeting. In Britain, which is outside the euro zone, the Bank of England left its benchmark interest rate unchanged at a record low of 0.5 percent.

As the US Federal Reserve has been creating new dollars at the rate of $85 billion a month under Quantitative Easing, the Fed's balance sheet has been growing, even as the ECB's balance sheet has been shrinking. And even though the Fed announced it would scale back those purchases by $10 billion a month, that just means the Fed balance sheet will continue growing, just not as fast. Or the bottom line; the Fed is creating money and the ECB is not.

Today, Mario Draghi, the president of the ECB said he wanted to “strongly emphasize” his earlier promise to keep monetary policy easy for as long as necessary. And Draghi said the ECB was “ready to consider all available instruments” to address either further weakness in consumer prices or increases in short-term money market rates that could put stress on banks. He did not, though, specify what tools he would use. The fear in Europe is that a nascent recovery could sputter and that low inflation (0.8% in December) could turn into deflation.

When asked if the euro crisis was over, Draghi said, “The recovery is there, but it’s fragile,” and it was too soon to declare victory. Even that might be a stretch. The unemployment problem for much of the euro-zone remains lousy; stuck at 12.1% for the past 9 months, and in some areas, youth unemployment is still around 50%, very dangerous levels. The problem for the ECB is essentially the same problem the Fed faces – how to improve aggregate demand. The ECB has been offering cheap money to the euro banks but the credit isn't getting through to companies and households. Lending to small businesses in the euro zone shrank 3.9% in November from a year ago, the biggest decline recorded by the ECB.

And with the Fed taper ready to kick in, the hope is that other countries and other central banks will pick up some slack in the world economy. Draghi has promised to do whatever it takes, and today he reiterated that promise, but that has been the promise for the past couple of years, and a couple of years can easily turn into a lost decade.

Here in the US, Ben Bernanke's farewell tour included a luncheon on Capitol Hill with Congress-folk, where he received a standing ovation and some of his past critics seemed to go soft. Bernanke offered an optimistic view of the economy, listing the country’s booming energy sector, stronger financial institutions and modest federal budget deficit reductions as positive signs.  Bernanke indicated he is more worried about the economic fate of middle-class families than the federal budget deficit going forward.

Meanwhile, the newly confirmed Federal Reserve Chairwoman, Janet Yellen has granted an interview to Time magazine and here's what she says about the economy: "I think we'll see stronger growth this year. Most of my colleagues on the Fed's policymaking committee and I are hopeful that the first digit [of GDP growth] could be 3 rather than 2... The recovery has been frustratingly slow, but were making progress in getting people back to work, and I anticipate that inflation will move back toward our longer-run goal of 2 percent." On the housing market, which had a brief lull this fall: "I expect it to pick back up and I do expect a further recovery."
Talking about the Fed's QE program, Yellen seems to believe that higher home prices and stock market stimulation is helping the average family. She is clearly a believer in the wealth effect, even though I have to question what data she might be looking at. RealtyTrac just released its Home Equity and Underwater Report for December 2013, which shows that 9.3 million US residential properties were deeply underwater, or about 1 in 5 of every property with a mortgage. "Deeply underwater" is defined as worth at least 25% less than the combined loans secured by the property. There are fewer homeowners who are deeply underwater, but there are still millions who are in serious trouble, and the longer these homeowners remain in a negative equity position without relief in the form of a principal loan balance reduction, the more likely that foreclosure will become the path of least resistance for them.


And on the jobs front, recent data from the Economic Policy Institute shows we're still about 1.3 million jobs below the pre-crisis peak – that's just to get back to break even, and then we would need about 6.6 million more jobs to get to where we need to be, in other words, how many jobs would be needed to employ all the people who would be actively looking for work if the economy were running at full steam.

The 7% unemployment rate is misleading because it is based partly on people dropping out of the work force and no longer being counted as unemployed. The economy is not strong enough to create jobs, so labor-force growth is not living up to its potential. If people who have dropped temporarily out of the labor force were still looking for jobs, the real unemployment rate would be 10.3%, not 7%. In other words, Dr. Yellen's confidence in the wealth effect never filtered down to the actual labor force.

If labor force participation drops, if for whatever reason, millions of people are no longer counted as part of the labor force, as is the case in the US, it’s a troublesome indicator for the economy and the real employment picture. It also makes the unemployment rate, now 7%, look a lot less awful: if you’re not counted in the labor force, and you don’t have a job, you’re not counted as unemployed. There are millions of people in that category. And their numbers are growing, not diminishing. The irony of the U-3 unemployment statistic is the fact that while unemployment has gone down 30% since its 2009 peak, we have the lowest labor force participation rate in over 3 decades.


People 55 to 64 years old, the first forget-about-retirement generation, are staying in the labor force to an ever greater degree. In 1992, only 56.2% were still in the labor force, in 2012, 64.5% were. Similar for older folks. The participation rate for people 65 to 74 years old jumped from 16.3% to 26.8%. Reality is this: fewer people can afford to retire. And the further reality is that the older workers are getting paid less.


The pattern among employers in a downturn in managing the non-executive/senior managerial workforce was to push out higher-cost older workers in favor of cheap, high energy, less set-in-their-ways new hires. Lots of people over 40 were given the heave-ho. Some eventually found work at much lower pay, some became self-employed (it’s a lot harder than the business press lets on; 9 out of every 10 new businesses fail in the first three years), and some retired, living more modestly than they had wanted to.


But who is not making it into the labor force? Young folks. The participation rate for those 16 to 19 has plunged from 51.3% in 1992 to 34.3% in 2012. OK, the BLS explains that by an increase in school attendance, and that would be a good thing. But the 25 to 54 year olds? Even among them, participation rates dropped from 83.3% in 2002 to 81.4% a decade later.
Among the 18 to 34 year old “Millennials,” those lucky ones who’re official counted in the labor force, unemployment has been a nightmare, with double digit unemployment rates, still, nearly 6 years after the financial crisis. It’s even worse for the 16 to 24 year olds, whose official unemployment rate is still 15%. In prior downturns, the employment rate for young adults nearly reached pre-recession levels within 5 years.

In the Great Recession, young adult employment had not even recovered halfway by the same point. A quarter of all job losses for young adults came after the Great Recession was officially over. The lack of jobs had driven many discouraged young people from the labor force altogether. A recent report by Opportunity Nation estimates that 5.8 million young adults are neither working nor in school.

And on the issue of banking reform Yellen says Dodd-Frank is a good road map but there may be a need for further steps. Which may be the biggest understatement of the new year. The Dodd-Frank reform legislation has been moving forward at a snail's pace, and the bank lobbyists are still in the process of re-writing bits and pieces and generally eviscerating key components. And even complete fulfillment of Dodd-Frank along current lines will not end the problem of “too big to fail.” 

Still, it's nice to see an incoming Fed head act like she'll pay attention to the Fed's role as a regulator. Under Alan Greenspan, the Fed was more of a deregulator than a regulator. Under Ben Bernanke, the Fed seemed to be more concerned with crisis control, and any thoughts of regulation were subservient to not letting the banking system implode, even if the bankers had lit the fuse. Now that there is some level of equilibrium, Yellen may actually feel emboldened to … ah hell, let's not get carried away; nothing will change.


Thursday, April 4, 2013

Thursday, April 04, 2013 - Experimental Therapies


The Wealth Protection Conference kicks off tomorrow afternoon in Tempe, Arizona. I will be the keynote speaker, starting at 4PM. This year's roster of speakers includes Mark Liebovit, Nathan Liles, David Smith, Roger Weigand, Arch Crawford, Ian McAvity, and Bill Tatro. These are some of the best technical analysts in the markets and top researchers and economic minds, and me. The conference is Friday and Saturday. For more information: www.buysilvernow.com. To make a reservation, please call 480-820-5877. I hope to see you there.

Experimental Therapies
by Sinclair Noe

DOW + 66 = 14,606
SPX + 6 = 1559
NAS + 6 = 3224
10 YR YLD - .05 = 1.76%
OIL – 1.07 = 93.38
GOLD – 4.30 = 1554.60
SILV- .08 = 27.00

A big day for central bankers. The European Central Bank left its benchmark interest rate unchanged at 0.75%, while the Bank of England held its key rate steady at 0.5%. With both central banks’ rates already at record lows, there might be little room to use interest rates as a stimulus. But the euro zone economies, like that of Britain, are stagnant and in need of help wherever they can find it. What to do when interest rates are already near zero? The Fed playbook calls for Quantitative Easing, and today the Bank of Japan took that playbook and put it on steroids.

First in Europe, ECB President Mario Draghi says the ECB was looking for new ways to stimulate lending in the weak euro zone economy, and could move quickly, but he didn't offer details of any new stimulus plan. Instead, Draghi tried to clean up some of the mess left by the botched Cyprus Bank Heist. Draghi emphasized the ECB's determination to shore up the euro and insisted that Cyprus is not a template for the future and is not a turning point in euro policy.

Draghi said the plan to steal small depositor was not smart, but things changed and they didn't steal from small depositors, only big depositors, and heck, a lot of them may or may not be Russians.

Meanwhile, economic reports showed a drop in business activity in France Germany. Draghi thinks the Eurozone will recover, but he acknowledged tight credit conditions are weighing on economic activity, and he generally looked like he didn't have any tools in his toolbelt.

Meanwhile, the Bank of England left rates unchanged. The BOE governor, Mervyn King has said he wants to try Quantitative Easing but he's been overruled by other members of the central bank’s interest rate setting committee; apparently content to wait a few months for the new governor, Mark Carney to see if he brings any new and exciting tools to his new job.

For a long time, Japan has resisted QE, and then they got a new Prime Minister in December, Shinzo Abe, and a new governor of their central bank, Haruhiko Kuroda; and today they announced an aggressive bid to end years of stagnation and deflation. The Japanese central bank said it would aggressively buy longer-term bonds and double its holdings of government bonds in two years, in effect doubling the money in circulation in the process.  They anticipate this will result in inflation; they hope it will result in inflation; they would love to see inflation surge to 2%. And if prices do not rise as expected, they promise to step up the bank’s easing program.  That represents a sea change from his predecessors, who were faulted for being too ready to pull back at the first sign of higher prices for fear of runaway inflation.

The BOJ will buy about 7-trillion-yen a month, which is equivalent to a bit more than 1% of gross domestic product, or about twice the pace of the Federal Reserve's QE bond buying plan. The policies are part of a new asset purchase framework that focuses on the monetary base instead of the overnight interest rate, which has remained close to zero for years doing little to increase prices or otherwise help the real economy. The bank will also consolidate all its purchases in a single operation in an attempt to improve transparency of the bank’s purchases.

Also, the bank will suspend a longstanding rule that limits its bondholdings to the amount of money in circulation, a limit that has already been surpassed.

Kuroda said that risks or doubts should not hold the central bank back from fighting deflation. He said: “We have debated the side effects, but we are currently not concerned that long-term interest rates might spike, or conversely, that there would be an asset bubble. That risks exist should not hold us back from pursuing much-needed monetary easing. We will keep in mind those risks, but push ahead.”

He also said that once Japan had fought off deflation and reignited its economy, lending would surely follow, spurring more economic growth in a virtuous cycle. One little side effect is a noticeable drop in the value of the yen.

So, we now have diametrically opposed central bank policy, a broad spectrum of plans to watch and evaluate. Japan has tossed the switch on wide open easing; the US has embraced Quantitative Easing with the effects muted by fiscal austerity; and the Eurozone seems content to accept month after month of seemingly meaningless and self-inflicted pain, or hyper-austerity. New numbers this week show the self-inflicted torment has resulted in 12% unemployment across the Eurozone; meaning some countries are in a worse economic condition than back in the Great Depression, which you may recall, ended in a bang, not a whimper.

Also this week we had some Federal Reserve doves indicating they would like to wean the US economy from QE to infinity and beyond, but this appears based on overly optimistic assumptions about the labor market. Of course we know this is just jawboning. Quantitative easing looks like it will never be reversed. Today's QE relies on pushing down borrowing costs. The idea is to encourage more credit, or more accurately it encourages more debt. That is a very blunt tool in a deleveraging bust when nobody wants to borrow.

The flip side is to push demand, a strategy that would require a more direct injection of capital into the economy, bypassing the debt cycle (and the banks); largely because the current policy has become dangerous, yielding ever less returns, with ever worsening side-effects.  It would be better for central banks to put the money into railways, bridges, clean energy, smart grids, or whatever does most to regenerate the economy. In other words, a direct injection that doesn't raise the debt; in other words, money printing. Yes, there might be some unintended side effects, but obviously, these are the days of grand experiments by central banks. In other words, nothing seems to be working, let's try flipping this switch.

The hope is that the hard days are passing and happy days will return, and the need for experimental therapies won't be necessary. Maybe the stock market is signaling a return to better days. Or maybe the stock market bull run is just an unintended side effect of the QE experiment. The stock market certainly seems disconnected from the economy. The M2 money stock has contracted over the past three months, and M2 velocity has dropped to the lowest ever recorded at 1.5. The country still has to navigate the sequester, a fiscal squeeze worth 2.5% of GDP over the rest of the year. Copper futures have dropped 10% since mid-February. Copper is the early warning signal for housing. The bull case for global recovery rests on US recovery, where the US is the economic engine pulling the world from the abyss; a seductive story as the housing market comes back to life and the shale boom revives the US chemical industry.

Tomorrow morning, we will get the monthly unemployment report for the Bureau of Labor Stats. It is expected the economy added about 190,000 jobs last month and the unemployment rate will hold steady at 7.7%.

The economy must add more than 360 thousand jobs each month for three years to lower unemployment to 6 percent. That would require growth in the range of 4 to 5 percent and is not likely with current policies. Tomorrow's jobs report will come 5 weeks after the start of the sequester; maybe too early to really feel the impact. Still, we'll watch the jobs report; since jobs are one of the better indicators of demand. And there will be no virtuous cycle without broad-based demand. If things truly start to get better, we'll happily get in line and march back to normalcy. If the jobs picture deteriorates, the experimental therapies will continue.








Tuesday, January 29, 2013

Tuesday, January 29, 2013 - Stimulus Truths and Tweaks


Stimulus Truths and Tweaks
by Sinclair Noe



DOW + 72 = 13,954
SPX + 7 = 1507
NAS – 0.6 = 3153
10 YR YLD +.03 = 2.00%
OIL + .88 = 97.32
GOLD + 9.40 = 1664.90
SILV + .54 = 31.48

We have a gaggle of economic reports this week and we'll try to keep up.

The Conference Board reported that its gauge of consumer confidence dropped to 58.6 in January, the lowest level since November 2011. Consumers are more pessimistic about the economic outlook and, in particular, their financial situation. The hike in the payroll tax is taking the brunt of the blame for the less-than-rosy outlook. Disposable income is actually declining. It's hard to be happy when your purse shrinks.

The sales price on existing homes dropped in November according to the S&P/Case-Shiller home-price index, down a non-seasonally adjusted 0.1% decrease in November following a 0.2% decline in October. After seasonal adjustments, the 20-city home-price index rose 0.6% in November. Despite the recent decline, prices were 5.5% higher than during the same period in the prior year, for the strongest year-over-year growth since August 2006.

Tomorrow, we'll get a glimpse of 4th Quarter GDP. The economy likely grew at a 1% pace, which is very weak.

Also tomorrow, The Federal Reserve wraps up its first FOMC meeting for the new year. They will likely continue with a fairly aggressive approach to stimulate the economy. In December, the Fed committed to adding $45 billion of monthly Treasury purchases to the existing QE3 program to buy $40 billion in mortgage debt a month. The purchase program has no end date. Last week the Bank of Japan announced a stimulus plan that includes US Treasury purchases. The Fed also adopted a new policy that targeted short-term interest rates to the outlook for unemployment, saying rates would stay low until the jobless rate falls below 6.5% as long as inflation stays tame.

The official unemployment rate is 7.8%, down from the 10% rate recorded in late 2009. Employment in the private sector has risen by more than 5 million over the past three years but it represents a sluggish recovery. Just over 12 million people are classified as unemployed (meaning they are actively looking for work), with an additional 6.5 million who aren’t looking but say they want a job; many of those people are long-term unemployed. Long-term unemployment imposes additional costs in the form of higher social spending and reduced economic output.

The unemployment rate in Europe is 10.7%, with 26 million out of work. Last week, the International Labor Organization reported nearly 200 million people worldwide are unemployed. Compared to the rest of the world, the US looks pretty good.

The British economy is flirting with a triple dip recession. The UK's gross domestic product fell 0.3 percent in the fourth quarter. One of the major problems has been a strong austerity program which cut investment spending. To be clear and fair, spending in the UK has changed composition rather than shrunk. Spending on social maintenance has gone up but investment spending has tanked. And of course I mean government investment spending, not private. This would indicate that removing government investment spending hurts the economy, not because it displaces private investment, but because it supplements and enhances private investment.


It’s not as if observers hadn’t warned about the effect of contractionary fiscal policy. In the summer of 2012, the IMF issued recommendations, saying deeper budget-neutral reallocations could support recovery. Such reallocations within the current overall fiscal stance could include greater investment spending funded by property tax reform or spending cuts on items with low multipliers. Automatic stabilizers should continue to operate freely. It will also be important to shield the poorest from the impact of consolidation.

The IMF said, scaling back fiscal tightening plans should be the main policy lever if growth does not build momentum by early-2013 even after further monetary stimulus and strong credit easing measures. Temporary easing measures in such a scenario should focus on infrastructure spending and targeted tax cuts, as they may be more credibly temporary.
It's not as if we haven't seen contractionary policies fail in the past. Andrew Mellon, as Secretary of the Treasury, advised Herbert Hoover: "Liquidate labor, liquidate stocks, liquidate farmers, liquidate real estate. It will purge the rottenness out of the system. High costs of living and high living will come down. People will work harder, live a more moral life. Values will be adjusted, and enterprising people will pick up from less competent people.”


So, the evidence continues to accumulate to overwhelming levels in favor of a front-loaded fiscal and monetary expansion, and the evidence supports the view that growth cannot be induced by contractionary policies in the current economic environment. And while tax increases could slow growth, there is no indication tax cuts in this environment are enough to encourage hiring.


One idea is to push US banks to lend more. The banks now have about $1.6 trillion in reserves parked at the Federal Reserve, not doing anything except making the banks feel safer. The Fed could put a cap on bank reserves, forcing the banks to do something with about $1 trillion in excess reserves, like lending it out to small businesses that are now being strangled by tight credit. It might help move money, but who will take a loan without a need. We have a demand problem, not a supply-side problem.


Any spending now, which would increase the deficit, must decrease the debt burden in the longer-term. In other words, we need investments, not just throwing money around. Infrastructure spending puts people to work n projects that promote economic growth. Those newly employed people spend their paychecks, circulating money, increasing the velocity of money in an otherwise stagnant environment. Economic growth is the optimal way to reduce the long-term debt burden. The money spent on infrastructure improves productivity and improves efficiency and saves us money over time.


We have neglected routine maintenance of our infrastructure for too long. We all know that it is cheaper to change the oil in our car's engine than it is to replace the engine. It is cheaper to fix a leak in the roof of the house than to interior of the house get soaked in a downpour. Pay now or pay more later.

But what about the cost versus benefit for new infrastructure? On the cost side, money is cheaper now than ever. Interest rates are near zero. High unemployment has reduced wage costs. On the benefits side, we have sufficient technological improvements to warrant upgrades in roads, bridges, water works, the electric grid, energy, transportation, and shipping in order to remain competitive globally.


Of course, there is an alternative lesson to be learned from the British triple dip. Some believe the UK government is desperate to keep interest rates as low as possible in order to avoid a housing market collapse where most mortgages go unpaid, which would result in the collapse of all UK banking – you know, something like a repeat of 2008. Also, if interest rates rise, interest payments on private and public debt would balloon. Further, if interest rates rise, the pound would strengthen, causing exports to slow even further.


According to this train of thought, in order to keep nominal interest rates low the UK government has chosen many years of recession as their strategy, because recession keeps down imports of oil and allows nominal interest rates to be low without triggering higher inflation, which is already running fairly high because of the higher cost of imports.


If nominal interest rates go up, and the housing market debubbles causing the collapse of the UK financial systems, the UK will be in an situation similar to Ireland or Lithuania, with a very sharp, long depression, instead of a milder, longer recession.


There is yet another possible motivation for the lack of investment in the US economy. The Fed is effectively printing profits to the largest Fed member institutions in exchange for MBS the banks have accumulated with cash from earlier sales to the Fed in lieu of lending because banks' net margin is negative in real terms after charge-offs and delinquencies as a share of loans.

All of the stimulus by the Fed is designed to disguise the fact that the banks still have hundreds of billions of dollars, if not trillions, in charge-offs to clear, which is preventing banksters from growing their loan books. "Stimulus" is really "bank liquidation".

In the meantime, the US government is borrowing and spending $1 trillion a year to prevent nominal GDP from contracting and thus forestall further contraction in bank assets and corporate profits, which are now at a record to GDP, as is non-financial corporate debt to GDP. Of course, that's just a theory and it does nothing to improve the unemployment picture, but it does provide a convenient target for the Federal Reserve to aim at, and keep just out of reach; this provides a reason for the Fed to continue QE because there is no viable exit strategy.

I'm sure there are plenty of other considerations or theories which might apply, but tweaking monetary and fiscal policies at the margins is largely irrelevant, and in an environment of tweaking, it leads to speculation. What this tells us is that there is a small window of opportunity to try to grow the economy. If we don't grow it now, it will be increasingly more difficult to grow it in the future.


Thursday, November 8, 2012

Thursday, November 8, 2012 - Tools in the Toolbox


Tools in the Toolbox
by Sinclair Noe

DOW – 121 = 12,811
SPX – 17 = 1377
NAS – 41 = 2895
10 YR YLD un = 1.63%
OIL + .60 = 85.04
GOLD + 14.60 = 1732.90
SILV + .47 = 32.41

Yesterday I was a guest on Bill Tatro's radio show: All About Money, 2PM Pacific and Mountain, right here on MoneyRadio. Most of the time Bill's show is Bill, and it's great; he's always entertaining and informative and I don't agree with everything he says but I think he does a great job of saying it; so I'm always a bit honored when he has me on as a guest. It's a different situation for me, being the guest, but Bill is an excellent interviewer. One of the questions he asked was, paraphrasing: “What tools does the Federal Reserve still have in their toolbox?”

I gave the basic answer that they didn't seem to have many tools left. I thought it was time for fiscal stimulus to match the Fed's already extraordinary use of monetary stimulus. But, as I said, this was a really good question and so I did a little more research, and today I'm going to talk with you about the tools left in the toolbox.

First, whether you like the Fed or not, the Fed's actions have had an impact on the economy and the economy has shown signs of recovery; I'm not sure what else to call it when you have 32 months of employment growth, the Dow Industrials have doubled from the lows of March 2009; not a great recovery but a recovery. Still we face a perilous path. This week's elections resulted in the status quo, there is still a fiscal cliff dead ahead, 9 of the countries in the Euro-Union are in a depression and the rest are facing recession and that affects the US, China is struggling. The IMF warned of a worldwide slowdown and the US is not immune. The path of austerity has has not worked in Europe, which should be no surprise because it didn't work in the United States back in the 1930s.

Corporate profits in the US are softening, the housing market still has a long way to go before it can be called normal again, and the average citizen is still concerned about jobs, and debt, and so they continue to keep a tight grip on their wallets.

There are a number of downside risks to the economy. We could see a shock that pushes the economy into another downward spiral, and if it happens again, it would probably be more difficult to contain than 4 years ago.

So, what's left for the Federal Reserve? Well, today, the Bank of England announced it would stop its bond buying program, the British equivalent of Quantitative Easing, and instead focus on a credit boosting initiative they call Funding for Lending Scheme, or FLS, to increase growth. The Bank of England also announced they would leave their benchmark interest rate at a record low 0.5%, while the European Central Bank announced they would hold steady at 0.75%. The thinking is that additional QE would only provide marginal benefits for the real economy, while creating longer-term risks of bubbles. Sound familiar? Of course, they could restart QE at any time but for now, they are looking at different tools.

The Funding for Lending Scheme means the British central bank will reward commercial banks with favorable rates if they provide more generous credit to help businesses wanting to expand and to create jobs. The scheme will also penalize banks if they fail to meet those goals. In other words, they will target bank lending.

The Fed actually has many tools to achieve their dual mandate to maintain stable money and maximum employment, but here's the deal, most of the tools the Fed has traditionally used tend to favor finance over industry, it works in favor of capital over labor, or Wall Street over Main Street. This has been a complaint for a long time. The Fed pumps money to the Wall Street bankers and they go out and gamble and the money never gets into productive hands. So, if the politicians are unwilling to stop acting like idiots (it may not be acting), then how can the Fed target money to the sectors that can really use it.

Well, in addition to running a printing press, it turns out that Bernanke is a pretty big-time regulator of the banking industry. The Fed could flex its regulatory muscle to unfreeze the risk-averse bankers who are still unwilling to lend—the same bankers whose reckless risk-taking nearly brought down the entire system four years ago. The Fed could create special facilities for directed lending (just as it did for the imperiled banking system) that gets the banks to relax lending terms for credit-starved sectors like small business. If bankers refuse to play, it could offer the same deal to financial institutions that are not banks.

What else? The Fed is already the biggest buyer and holder of mortgage backed securities; which is another way of saying they have quasi-nationalized the mortgage industry; and since they hold almost all the paper, who's to say they can't reduce debt for millions of underwater home mortgages? They've already managed to smooth the path to refinancing for millions of underwater homeowners; why not push debt reducing loan mods as well?

The Fed could also provide financing for major infrastructure projects: they could modernize the electric grid; they could finance green energy; they could build high speed rail systems or urban light rail; they can finance major road and bridge construction; massive water works projects; they could even finance education. The Fed could influence the investment decisions of private capital by backstopping public-private bonds needed to finance the long-neglected overhaul of the nation’s common assets.

But wait, wait (I can hear some of you sputtering right now) wait! The Fed can't do that! That's the job of the Congress; that's why we elect politicians, to make those kinds of decisions. If Bernanke crosses that line, it would surely be illegal. And I'm sure, Bernanke would like congressional cooperation, and he wants to avoid confrontation if possible.

Maybe Bernanke has already found an ally in the White House who is also exasperated with the obstructionist policies of the Republican leaders in Congress. And maybe that ally just won re-election and if the Republicans try to throw their weight around, he might just flex his own muscles.

Make no mistake, the Fed can carry out direct interventions to help the economy recover, it is legal, and it has used this power before, plenty of times. During the Great Depression, the Federal Reserve was given open-ended legal authority to lend to practically anyone if its Board of Governors declared an economic emergency. This remains the law today. The central bank can lend to industrial corporations and small businesses, including partnerships, individuals, and other entities that are not commercial banks or even financial firms. The Fed made thousands of direct loans to private businesses during the New Deal, and the practice continued for twenty years. Only in more recent times has the reigning conservative doctrine insisted that this cannot be done. 

The original authorizing legislation for such lending was enacted in 1932 as Section 13.3 of the Federal Reserve Act, and the wording was left deliberately vague. An emergency was defined as “unusual and exigent circumstances.” Whatever did that mean? In practice, it meant whatever the Board of Governors decided it meant. Fed governors must now get approval from the treasury secretary, but they do not have to ask Congress for permission. 
Section 13.3 is often depicted as antique legislation left over from the New Deal, but the provision is very much alive and active. It was invoked during the crisis of 2008. When Bear Stearns collapsed in the spring of 2008, the Fed declared “unusual and exigent circumstances” to legitimize its rescue. Bear Stearns was a brokerage house, not a bank. And then Section 13.3 was again use to justify the $180 billion bailout of American International Group. AIG is not a bank but a giant insurance company, and it was obviously insolvent. Normally, a failed corporation would proceed to bankruptcy court, where its creditors would fight over what was left. In this case, the Fed stepped in to save AIG.
The AIG bailout was not very popular, and so Congress tightened up the old law. Now, the Fed can still lend to “individuals, partnerships and corporations” if they are “unable to secure adequate credit accommodations from other banking institutions.” But it can no longer create a special lending facility to protect a single insolvent company.
Fed money is not exactly “free,” but it has this great virtue for government: it doesn’t cost the taxpayers anything; there may be ramifications but it's different than tax revenue. Fed expenditures do not show up in the federal budget, nor do they add anything to the national debt. Think of what this means when it comes time to negotiate the fiscal cliff? In a sense, this freshly created money belongs to the people, it's our money, and can be used in unusual ways to advance the shared public interest. Lincoln did this when he printed “greenbacks” during the Civil War. Various Fed governors have done it when they were faced with “unusual and exigent circumstances.” And don't forget the bailout of Penn Central. And, of course, the Fed used this to lend extensively during the Great Depression. And don't forget that Bernanke is a student of the Great Depression.
Does the Fed have any tools left in the toolbox? You better believe it. 


Thursday, July 5, 2012

Thursday, July 5, 2012 – The Incredibly Massive Libor Scandal, Snakes, Plus the Halftime Report

The Incredibly Massive Libor Scandal, Snakes, Plus the Halftime Report
by Sinclair Noe


DOW – 47 = 12,896
SPX – 6 = 1367
NAS +.03 = 2976
10 YR YLD -.03 = 1.60
OIL +4.46 = 92.12
GOLD – 12.80 = 1604.90
SILV - .59 = 27.80
PLAT – 16.00 = 1479.00


It was a busy day for the central bankers. It started with the Bank of England. A couple of months ago, the BoE stopped bond purchases; today they resumed the practice. The Bank of England Governor, Mervyn King announced they will increase bond purchase to 375-billion-pounds, or about $585-billion-dollars. They think this will help pull the UK from recession but they admit output will likely remain sluggish after contracting for the past two months. 


A few minutes later, the People's Bank of China cut its key interest rate for the second time in a month  and allowed banks to offer bigger discounts on their own lending costs. The one-year lending rate will fall by 31 basis points to 6 percent and the one-year deposit rate will drop by 25 basis points to 3 percent effective tomorrow. Banks can offer loans of as much as 30 percent less than benchmark rates.


A few minutes later, the European Central Bank cut its key interest rate by 25 basis points to a record low of 0.75 percent. ECB President Mario Draghi questioned the economic impact of cutting rates but did it anyway. He said the ECB is not “running low on policy options” but he didn't say what the other options are. 


Draghi claimed this was not part of a coordinated move by the various global central banks, and that there had been nothing beyond typical communications. The Federal Reserve expanded Operation Twist on June 20th. The central banks of Australia, the Czech Republic, Kazakhstan, Vietnam and Israel also cut rates in June, while the Swiss National Bank is buying euros to defend its franc ceiling.
Bank of Japan officials meet next week to review their forecasts.


So, will all of this non-coordinated monetary policy help?  The UK economy is so stressed that 90 percent of the money the central bank is injecting could end up in risk-free assets or reserves. Chinese investors are already calling for stimulus efforts and economic reforms. The ECB cut isn't expected to have much impact and there are calls for quantitative easing – they might also want to figure out how the whole monetary union should be structured and then figure out if they want to keep it in place or tear it apart. Seven of the 17 economies in the Euro-union need to be bailed out. In other words, 41% of the Euro-union is in trouble, and the Euro-union represents 25% of the global economy. 


The question is: where will the necessary spark to rekindle global growth come from? Wherever it will come from, we didn't see it today. 


Back here in the good ole USA, tomorrow's big monthly jobs report is expected to show 90,000 new jobs added to the economy. Goldman Sachs today said they thought the number will be better, closer to about 125,000. If it comes in less than 125k that means Goldman was shorting the market; if the number comes in significantly higher it means they were long. There is no way in hell I would ever trust Goldman on anything. 


There is an old story of a woman walking down a country path in winter. There is snow and ice and it is very cold. She comes upon a snake in the path; the snake is nearly frozen. The snake says: “Take me in. Save me.” The woman says: “You're a snake. I can't trust you. You will bite me.” The snake says: “No, I won't bite you. I beg you. If you take me in I will do everything I can to repay you. You can trust me.” The old woman takes the snake to her home. She warms the snake near the fire. She feeds the snake. A couple days later, the snake is feeling healthy. The snake bites the old woman. The woman says: “You promised you wouldn't bite me.” The snake says: “Yeah, but I'm a snake. What did you expect?”


And that brings us back to the latest scandal in a never-ending string of banking scandals; this one involving Barclays and big lies about Libor, the London Interbank Offer Rate. Already there have been resignations, including the CEO Bob Diamond, who was forced to testify before the House of Commons. 


During a three-hour grilling by MPs, Diamond told the treasury select committee of his disgust when he learned that traders at Barclays had manipulated interest rates in 2005. "When I read the emails from those traders I got physically ill. It is reprehensible behaviour and if you are asking me should those actions be dealt with – absolutely."


Asked when he learned of the practice of rate rigging – known as low balling – Diamond indicated that he only learnt about it when he was shown a report a few days before its publication. "The finding of the investigation, other than the things I learnt as a witness, came to me four or five days before they were published."


So, Diamond knew nothing; he wasn't involved in anything; and basically, all the banks across the world were fixing interest rates as they tried to lie and cheat and do anything they could to survive the financial crisis.


The chief investigator said: "I think, cumulatively, the whole package looks somewhat implausible."


You do understand that this is an enormously huge scandal, and if Diamond is correct that all the other banks were doing it, and that part is plausible, then the implications are massive. You might think I'm exaggerating because you watched the nightly news yesterday and there was no mention. The reason is that the nightly news thinks we are too stupid to understand the manipulation of interest rates. 




But let me explain the basics: from 2005 and 2007, the bank allegedly varied the rates it reported to the British Bankers Association so as to improve its margins on internal trades. For example, Barclays could have placed bets that the LIBOR rate would increase, and then reported artificially high rates which in turn artificially increased the LIBOR averages, so that the bets were likelier to pay off. This bumped up mortgage rates – however infinitesimally – for consumers even when the risk of the loans hadn’t changed at all. It wasn't a big jump, but it was a little jump. And there are 16 banks that report the rates to the BBA each and every day, and so there were others that were complicit in this rate rigging scandal in addition to Barclays. This is a banking cartel.


 The Libor market is incredibly huge, so little moves can be extremely profitable. That was just part of the scandal – the second part involved lying about the rate as a way to pump up their financial strength, basically they lied about their credit score. 


For example: 60% of prime adjustable mortgage rates were tied to Libor, and about 100% of subprime mortgages were tied to Libor; there are approximately $10 trillion in mortgages just in the US. So just a few basis points can make a big difference; and then credit card debt and student loans and basically almost all loans were tied to the Libor rate. And then there's about $350 trillion in credit swaps tied to the Libor. So almost every major corporation and most of the municipalities got a little haircut when the rates were manipulated. And the overall market tied to the Libor rates is about $800 trillion, or about 10 times the Gross Domestic product of the entire world. And Barclays and the other banks just took a little cut, just enough to wet their beaks. They stole, just a little bit, from everything because Libor is at the center of all credit. And if we are to believe Bob Diamond, all the bankers were cheating and were corrupt.


Are you surprised? This is the very nature of the big banks. They were given the green light that the rules did not apply to them. The same bank executives that crashed the global financial system in 2008, the worst breakdown since the Great Depression, the same guys are still running the same banks. Bob Diamond is not a newbie at Barclays. And the entire system is completely and totally rotten to the core.  And this is an enormously huge problem. And everywhere you look – snakes.






It is time for the Halftime Report.


On January 5, 2012 we talked with Evan Greenberg, an old friend and former hedge fund manager. Evan specializes in finding small cap stocks. Years ago we started doing a Top Ten List. Evan picked 10 small cap stocks, at the end of the year we would tally the price and see how it worked out. Over several years, this method resulted in a couple of gains over 100%, and gains every year.


The rules of the game: small and micro cap stocks only; pick the stocks in January; no trades in or out; don't count dividends or trading costs.  Five of the Top Ten are showing gains, while 5 are showing losses. On a per share basis, the returns are a positive 6.6%
Here is the list and the prices from Jan.5, in no particular order:


10. USHS – U.S. Home Systems =$7.24
9. TGE – TGC Industries =7.16
8. DLA – Delta Apparel = 19.25
7. PESI - Perma-Fix Solutions = 1.56
6. ANIK – Anika Therapeutics = 9.60
5. FRD – Friedman Industries = 11.29
4. CECE – CECO Environmental = 5.67
3. CVU – CPI Aerostructures = 13.03
2. ACET – Aceto Corp = 6.83
1.HURC – Hurco Companies = 21.58


The 5 gainers to date are USHS, TGE, ANIK, CECE, and ACET. Evan still likes FRD, CVU, CECE, and ACET in particular. If he could add three more small caps to the list, they would be: MOSY, MNTG, and MITL.  Among the large caps, Evan likes MSFT and NVDA. His favorite short is LULU. 
To contact Evan send email to: Egreenberg@legendcap.com
Good luck and you're welcome.