Showing posts with label protests. Show all posts
Showing posts with label protests. Show all posts

Tuesday, June 18, 2013

Tuesday, June 18, 2013 - The Fed, and the Brazilian Protests

The Fed, and the Brazilian Protests
by Sinclair Noe

DOW + 138 = 15,318
SPX + 12 = 1651
NAS + 30 = 3482
10 YR YLD + .01 = 2.18%
OIL + .63 = 98.02
GOLD – 16.40 = 1369.30
SILV – .16 = 21.78

The past couple of years, the financial markets have been very dependent on the Federal Reserve, perhaps overly dependent. Much of the fundamental analysis of companies and the economy has taken a backseat to the Fed's unprecedented monetary policy of Quantitative Easing. The outlook for the financial markets for the remainder of the year boils down to potential changes in policy. The Federal Open Market Committee has begun its regularly scheduled policy meeting and tomorrow they will issue a policy statement followed by a press conference by Fed Chairman Bernanke.

So, this time tomorrow we'll know more but given the importance of monetary policy, it's worthwhile to consider possibilities and possible market response. There are four possible scenarios to consider:

The first scenario has the Fed announcing preparations for tapering off QE; they won't actually stop QE tomorrow, they'll just announce their intention to exit QE policy at some identifiable point down the road; and of course, it would be conditional on economic developments between now and the determined exit date; it would most like involve scaling back securities purchases without any specific targets for changing interest rates. This seems to be the most probable scenario right now.

Since the Fed announced QE3 last September, the Bank of Japan has started their own $75 billion per month stimulus policy, known as Abenomics. There are fears that the combination of QE3 and Abenomics might have a destabilizing effect. There is no indication the Japanese are backing away from their stimulus program, and there is indication the Euro-zone might consider some sort of monetary stimulus program. So, if the Fed backs down, that leaves room for other central bankers to maneuver.

The other three scenarios for tomorrow's announcement are far less likely. The Fed could announce an immediate tapering off from securities purchases; this is not likely; former Fed Chairman Greenspan tried this in 1994 and it was messy. The only reason the Fed might try this is to shock the markets, inducing a flight to safe havens such as Treasuries, and applying pressure on the politicians to come up with something that resembles fiscal policy. This is risky, like dancing on a carpet of banana peels.

The other scenario involves the Fed announcing that it is continuing with stimulus but it will consider a different mix. In other words, instead of buying $85 billion a month in Treasuries and mortgage backed securities, they will consider other purchases. They might consider student loan debt or state or municipal debt. Again, this would be a bit of a shock but it makes some sense.

The housing market has benefited from the Fed purchasing mortgage backed securities; meanwhile, student loan debt is starting to resemble the subprime markets of a few years back; defaults are on the rise and a meltdown would be ugly.

Likewise, there are several municipalities that could benefit from an infusion of capital from the Fed. Several cities in California are bankrupt. Detroit is insolvent and facing the prospect of default on $17 billion, including pension payments. They have a tightrope balancing act between the legacy obligations to creditors, employees, and retirees and their obligation to the residents of the city to continue to provide basic services. Right now there are 30 fires per day in Detroit. If they cut back on the Fire Department, the whole city could burn. Yes, some of those fires are deliberate.

There are other areas the Fed could consider that would offer a more direct infusion of capital directly into the economy, and they could do this in small steps; stepping back from Treasury or MBS purchases as the markets fluctuate; stepping into brave new arenas as needed. This is a highly unlikely approach but it would offer the biggest bang for the Federal Reserve Note.

The final scenario is that the Fed doesn't change anything tomorrow. Why should they? When they announced QE3, they said they would continue until they reached a target of either 6.5% unemployment or 2.5% inflation. Inflation remains below the Fed’s 2% target. The core consumer price index is up just 1.7% year-on-year in May. The central bank’s preferred measure, the index for personal consumption expenditures, is up only 0.7%. The economy has been adding jobs but the unemployment rate still stands at 7.6%; that's a long way from the target. While some might consider tapering to be an indication the Fed thinks economic recovery is stronger than it looks, an exit from QE now would be an admission of monetary policy failure. Consider it the central bank equivalent of a “Mission Accomplished” banner.

The Fed may ultimately decide that the economy or the markets are simply not ready and that announcing any intention to taper in the coming months may cause more harm to capital markets than its worth. This leaves the Fed with the option to do more jawboning in the future; it leaves them with the option of shocking the markets; it leaves them with more time to figure out alternative monetary policy; and it leaves them with more time to try to see beneficial returns on QE3 before they burn that bridge. Maybe Bernanke would just as soon leave the exit from QE to the next Fed Chairman.

Whatever the Fed announces tomorrow, it will likely rattle the markets. Both stocks and bonds would likely have a party if the Fed holds steady with no changes. The markets love free money from the Fed and no change might just be enough to provide a summer rally; a little boost for the economy.

Stocks would likely take any tapering news poorly. Any news of intention to taper might be enough to push stocks into a summer swoon; and then we would wait to see if that leads to a full fledged bear. At the very least, it would take a little of the exuberance out of stocks. That might not be such a bad thing; the S&P 500 is up about 22% over the past 12 months; there has been a disconnect between the stock market at 20% and the broader economy, which has been growing at a little less than 2%. Any news of intention to taper would likely be positive for bonds in the short term with a flight to safety, at least that was the history following the end of QE1 and QE2.

Tune in tomorrow.

Yesterday, I mentioned that there had been quite a few protests around the world. I listed about a dozen locations where protesters had taken to the streets in huge numbers. I didn't even mention Turkey. I did mention Brazil, where the normally laid back Brazilians took to the streets. Yesterday, the Brazilian protests really picked up steam. It started on Saturday, when the FIFA Confederation Soccer matches began in Brasilia. President Dilma Rouseff was scheduled to make an announcement before the game. The government had spent about $600 million to build a beautiful new soccer stadium, part of the 2014 World Cup. Rousseff was booed relentlessly; she cut short her speech and quickly exited the stage.

You may hear that the Brazilians are upset about a rate increase in bus and subway fares. That's not what the protests are about, or at least it's just a small part. The Brazilians are upset that the government has spent tens of billions preparing for the World Cup, with allegations of corruption; projects are already vastly over-budget and we are a year away. Meanwhile Brazil continues to invest below the OECD average in education. Public health expenditure is even lower. People are going hungry.

Rio de Janeiro consistently ranks amongst the most expensive cities in the world, while minimum wage remains low, about $300 per month. Sao Paulo, the country's financial center is even worse. It is home to the highest concentration of private jets and helicopters in the world, but the lower and middle classes have no access to decent schools and hospitals; and the poor people rely on public transportation. When residents of the two cities took to the streets last weekend bearing placards and chanting slogans demanding answers, regional police responded by firing rubber bullets and tear gas and violent beatings.

In response, the Brazilians took to the streets yesterday in massive numbers. The official estimates were more than 100,000 protesters in downtown Rio; the unofficial numbers topped a quarter million. The international media has also been peculiarly disinterested on the subject, even if coverage of the protests in Turkey, similar in nature to Brazil's, has been extensive and detailed. Spain's El Pais suggested the Brazilian protests have left the international community baffled as the country is consistently painted as a model for growth and development; Brazil is now the world's sixth largest economy, growing rapidly; Brazilians have nothing to complain about.

Certainly the Brazilian government thought that the populace would be distracted by soccer; and while it is true that Brazilians love soccer, it turns out it wasn't enough of a distraction. While there has been economic growth, there has also been growing inequality, and growing poverty. And the World Cup has just highlighted the inequality. The minimum wage of $300 a month is the average price of one ticket to one World Cup soccer game. Soccer was once a game that brought all Brazilians together; now the World Cup just rubs their noses in the fact that they are further apart than ever.

The big reason inequality is now a regular topic of conversation among economists is that the rapid rise of a super rich class while average workers are left in the dust makes it impossible to ignore. The IMF and the World Bank have just released a report showing that at the same time US companies are taking down a record share of GDP in profits, our country’s ranking in inequality is worse than that of many developing economies. New York City is more unequal than China, and also more unequal than Russia, famed for its oligarchs, and India, which still has hundreds of millions living in abject poverty.



Monday, June 17, 2013

Monday, June 17, 2013 - Preaching, Practicing, and Doing

Preaching, Practicing, and Doing
by Sinclair Noe

DOW + 109 = 15,179
SPX + 12 = 1639
NAS + 28 = 3452
10 YR YLD + .05 = 2.17%
OIL + .07 = 97.92
GOLD – 6.80 = 1385.70
SILV - .24 = 21.94

President Obama is in Northern Ireland today, part of a three-day European tour that includes a G-8 summit meeting. Maybe we could call this the “Practice what I preach, not what I practice Tour”. Obama kicked off the tour with a speech in Belfast to celebrate Northern Ireland's peace process; later he'll talk with Euro leaders, including Russian President Putin about lifting a European arms embargo to arm Syrian rebels.

The G-8 summit generally deals with economic issues, and tops on the list will be tax evasion. The Brits, lead by David Cameron and George Osborne will pressure for a comprehensive deal to include developing countries while preventing developed countries from trying to water down proposals. The two big ideas include having the beneficial ownership of offshore accounts made public and then having the G-8 countries commit to a global agreement on exchange of tax information that developing countries can join. The concern for poorer countries is that the G8 will deliver a "gold standard" for itself but offer a less satisfactory agreement for poor countries, which lose three times as much in tax evasion as they gain from aid.

The Syrian conflict might actually be a positive for pushing through a deal on tax havens. It is unlikely there will be an agreement on Syria, and so the G-8 might push through something on tax evasion to be seen as having accomplished something. Of course, a deal on tax evasion is not a good bet. The issue is much more prominent in Euro-land, where multinational companies like Google and Apple and Starbucks have been playing the system and stiffing taxpayers. The mega corporations tend to stiff US taxpayers as well, but we haven't raised a ruckus about it. In Euro-land, it's a hot topic. Don't be surprised if the G-8 does little more than agree to discuss it in the future.

There will also be talk about a transatlantic trade deal between the European Union and the US, but then there has been talk about a deal for years. The US and the EU already trade about $1 trillion a year in goods and services and invest another $4 trillion in each others economies, and most of that is already free of tariffs; a trade deal would look to eliminate the rest. As you might suspect, there are multiple industries that want to protect their turf.

Then there is the idea of how to stimulate economic growth. A couple of months ago, Treasury Secretary Jack Lew talked to Euro-leaders and urged them to avoid austerity. Last week, the International Monetary Fund said an excessively rapid and ill-designed deficit reduction plan had hampered a tepid recovery in the US economy. Against that backdrop, the Federal Reserve FOMC is meeting this week in Washington.

The time is nearing for the Federal Reserve to scale back its program of Quantitative Easing to support the economy, which involves buying $85 billion in bonds each month. It's clear that QE can't go on forever, but divisions remain over when it will start tapering its bond purchases. At some point there will be an exit, and the Fed will almost certainly provide plenty of warning, well in advance of any exit.

The central bank’s Federal Open Market Committee will meet on Tuesday and Wednesday, and issue a statement at the conclusion on Wednesday, followed shortly after by a news conference by the Fed chairman, Ben Bernanke.

How does the Fed announce an exit of QE, while the President is in Europe urging the G-8 to avoid austerity? It will be a balancing act that involves a fair bit of shaming the Congress for failure to deliver fiscal policy, combined with a fair bit of cheer leading for the strength of the US economy. A positive economic assessment from the Fed might also serve as a gift wrapped present for the remainder of the G-8, who appear to be in a race to drop the value of their currencies.

The Fed's primary challenge is to drive home the idea that while the economy may be improving, there is still uncertainty surrounding the bond-buying outlook. Central bankers also need to repeat what they’ve been saying in speeches: Smaller bond buying won’t represent a tightening in monetary policy, just a reduction in the amount of stimulus the Fed is delivering. It’s a crucial point, and how they deliver the message will determine, in part, how the bond market responds. So, it is now widely anticipated that the Fed will fine tune it's monetary policy this week. Or they might not do anything. Stay tuned.

The Supreme Court announced a couple of rulings this morning.

First, the court struck down an Arizona law that required people registering to vore in federal elections to show proof of citizenship. In a 7-2 vote, the court, in an opinion written by conservative Justice Antonin Scalia, ruled the voter registration provision of the 2004 state law was trumped by a federal law, the 1993 National Voter Registration Act.

The other decision announced today says federal regulators can sue drug companies for antitrust violations when brand-name drug makers pay generic competitors to keep cheaper, rival copies of a drug off the market.

In a decision that shifts the balance of power in the drug business, manufacturers will now have to defend the agreements against charges that they violate anticompetition laws, perhaps exposing the companies to a greater likelihood of aggressive competition from generic drugs and to lawsuits from drug retailers and wholesalers, insurers and others. Consumers also could benefit from sharply lower drug costs.

The court did not address whether the agreements, called pay-for-delay or reverse payments, were presumptively unlawful. But it laid out a number of possibilities under which the contracts could be attacked by antitrust officials.

The case pitted a company’s constitutional right to protect its intellectual property, through reliance on a patent that excludes competitors, against antitrust law, which holds that a company cannot unfairly exclude others from legitimately entering a business with a rival product.

According to affidavits filed in a Massachusetts lawsuit against Bank of America, the bank routinely denied qualified borrowers a chance to modify their loans to more affordable terms and paid cash bonuses to bank staffers for pushing homeowners into foreclosure.

In sworn testimony, six former employees describe what they saw behind the scenes of an often opaque process that has frustrated homeowners, their attorneys and housing counselors.  They describe systematic efforts to undermine the program by routinely denying loan modifications to qualified applicants, withholding reviews of completed applications, steering applicants to costlier "in-house" loans and paying bonuses to employees based on the number of new foreclosures they initiated. 

Five big banks-including Bank of America-settled a sweeping complaint with 49 states and several federal regulators about their foreclosure and loan modification practices. 

Bank of America agreed to abide by HAMP program guidelines, which require it to modify loans for qualified buyers, when it accepted $25 billion in bailout funds from the government in 2008 following the housing collapse. In return for the financial lifeline, the bank agreed to help millions of struggling homeowners by rewriting mortgages with more affordable terms. As an added incentive, the government agreed to pay a cash bonus for every loan that was modified successfully. But, according to the former employees, while the bank was lying to borrowers, it was also falsifying its performance when reporting to the government the number of loans that had been modified. 

Later this week, a monitor assigned to track the bank's practices will issue a report that's expected to cite ongoing violations of those new rules.

What does it take to get people off the couch? Who knows? We don't seem to protest much in the US anymore. It's common elsewhere around the world. The BBC reports more than 1,000 public protests per month in Egypt so far this year. A few hundred marched in Hong Kong shouting  “Shame on NSA! Defend freedom of speech!” They carried signs written in Chinese and English and wrapped in plastic to keep out the rain. “Protect Snowden!” In Indonesia at least 4,000 people took to the streets today to protest the governments plan to raise the subsidized price of fuel. Tens of thousands of people held a rally near Malaysia’s capital against alleged electoral fraud. Around 7,500 people participated in anti-nuclear protests in Tokyo. Yemeni security officials say thousands have protested in the capital against “excesses” by security forces, calling for the overthrow of the president and national security apparatus. Greeks set up an encampment outside th state broadcaster, Hellenic Radio and Television, after it was shut down by the Prime Minister. Some 15,000 people protested in Bulgaria yesterday about the appointment of a new national security chief. More than 3,000 Chinese villagers have maintained a 24-hour silent vigil for the past 12 days over a coal mine, which they say has devastated the ground near their homes, swallowed up a road, and left cracks in their houses. Thousands of Canadians marched in downtown Montreal on Saturday to protest changes in employment insurance. Portuguese teachers are on nationwide strike, right during final exams. And thousands of Brazilians protested increased bus and subway fares in Sao Paulo and Rio de Janeiro. Those protests have been going on for ten days, and police have been firing tear gas canisters and rubber bullets at the crowds.

The world is an edgy place these days.