Showing posts with label bond market. Show all posts
Showing posts with label bond market. Show all posts

Friday, May 30, 2014

Friday, May 30, 2014 - Record Highs, Bonds, Coal Mines

Record Highs, Bonds, Coal Mines
by Sinclair Noe

DOW + 18 = 16,717
SPX + 3 = 1923 (another record)
NAS – 5 = 4242 (not a record)
10 YR YLD + .01 = 2.45%
OIL - .71 =  102.87
GOLD – 4.60 = 1252.30
SILV - .23 = 18.91

For the week, the Dow rose 0.7%, the S&P 500 gained 1.2% and the Nasdaq added 1.4%. For the month of May, the Dow gained 0.8%, the S&P 500 rose 2.1% and the Nasdaq climbed 3.1%. Meanwhile, if you are looking for action, the bond market is the place; the yield on the 10 year note has dropped from 2.65% to 2.45% this month.

Nearly everyone is looking for an explanation as to why longer-term interest rates continue to fall in the face of reduced Fed support and what is being hyped as better economic data. This wasn’t supposed to happen. The Federal Reserve has been propping up Treasury bond prices, and suppressing yields, for the past several years by buying large quantities of bonds each month in an effort to increase investment and consumption, and force investors into riskier assets. To some extent, the Fed’s QE purchases have worked; ultra-low interest rates have supported housing price increases and have led to skyrocketing stock prices.  Household net worth has increased by $25 trillion from the financial-crisis lows in the first quarter of 2009.  However, these gains in net worth have overwhelmingly accrued to the well-to-do while low- to moderate-income folks continue to suffer from poor employment opportunities, stagnant incomes, inadequate retirement savings, and rising costs for everything from food and energy to health care and education.  In other words, the economy hasn’t really improved but the Fed may have created financial asset bubbles.

Last December the Fed began winding down its large scale asset purchases by tapering, or incrementally reducing the amount of purchases over a scheduled period of a year or so. Back in December the Fed was buying $85 billion a month in mortgage backed securities and treasuries; they have now cut that to just $45 billion a month, and by the end of the year they anticipate they will end the large scale asset purchases. This means that demand for treasuries and MBS has, or should have dropped significantly. If there is less demand and the supply stays the same, then prices should fall and bond yields should be moving higher. The exact opposite has been happening; long term bond prices have increased and bond yields have been falling; and the timing of this increase in prices and drop in yields coincides with the start of the Fed taper.

Is there something wrong with the supply/demand equation? Is there invisible demand out there? Well, treasuries are considered a safe haven investment, and if we saw volatility in the stock market, we might expect a move to the safe haven of treasuries. Right now the CBOE Volatility Index known as the VIX, is down. As the 10-year yield touches the 2.4% level, its lowest in nearly a year, the VIX is hovering around 11.5, near its lowest levels since before the financial crisis.

The VIX measures volatility in the US market, so maybe we need to broaden out horizons. Europe is experiencing low-flation, and in some Euro countries the low-flation has turned to deflation; as a consequence, the rates in Europe are very low: German 10 year bonds yield 1.36%, France yields 1.75%, Spain 10 year notes yield 2.86%. In a global market there is something wrong with pricing. Why is the US bond yield higher than the French bond yield? That does not compute.

Of course, one explanation is that foreign investors are looking for a place to park money and if you can get a better yield on US treasuries compared to French bonds, it just makes sense that you wouldn’t buy the French bonds; add in the idea that buying US treasuries serves as an effective hedge against home currency depreciation and treasuries should be attracting money that might be held in emerging market economies.

In general, if economic growth is expected to accelerate, interest rates should rise as well.  The reason for this is fairly straightforward.  Increased demand for goods and services should lead to price increases.  Inflation is one component of "nominal" interest rates.  The other component is called the "real" rate of interest, and it is determined by the demand for money.  As economic growth accelerates, the demand for money should increase as people become more confident in making spending and investment decisions.  Therefore, higher inflation expectations and higher demand for money should lead to higher interest rates in a strengthening economy; but they haven't. Perhaps the weak economy of the Eurozone is holding back rates in the US, or maybe the US economy isn’t as strong as we imagine.

Another consideration has us going back to the supply-demand equation; if supply dries up faster than demand dries up, then that would push prices higher. Remember that the federal deficit has been trimmed to the lowest levels in about 13 years and that means the government isn’t issuing as much new debt. And the housing market has slowed and that means there should be less in the way of mortgage backed securities.

That was certainly the case for the first quarter; the US economy shrank. And there are no real signs of inflation in the US, or at least we didn’t see inflation for quite some time. That may be changing; the April CPI and PPI showed a minor pop in prices; the low interest rate environment has boosted financial asset prices, so stocks and housing prices have moved higher; food prices are also higher but they tend to be overlooked as a weather related aberration, although I doubt that is temporary; the labor market is still weak and despite the unemployment rate dropping to 6.3% there is tremendous slack and little participation and there doesn’t seem to be any wage inflation. The Fed might claim the economy is getting stronger and the Fed might not consider deflation to be a problem, but the bond market seems to be saying the recovery is sick. At least for the Main Street economy.

Further proof today showing American shoppers dialed it back in April. Household purchases fell 0.1%, the first decrease in a year, and following a 1% gain in March; that was the bounce back from the pent up demand of the frozen winter. After adjusting the figure to account for inflation, the news was worse; spending dropped by the most since September 2009 as income growth cooled. Incomes advanced just 0.3% in April, and without pay gains, consumers lack confidence. Consumer sentiment dropped from 84.1 in April to 81.9 in May. What we’re seeing is the failure of trickledown. The stock market may be strong, the well-off may be better off, but it doesn’t trickle down. The economy is never going to recovery without broad based demand, and that will only happen when the labor market gets strong, until then, the Fed is pushing on a string with QE and the Zero Interest Rate Policy.

There are many possible reasons behind the move in bonds, but a big part still has to do with the economy, even with all the subplots of the international markets and the inflation-deflation debate, we get back to the idea that the economy is weak, and the recovery is uneven. The first quarter GDP contraction was certainly weather related but that doesn’t mean the economy will bounce like a quarter on a trampoline. Second quarter GDP should be positive but probably not sizzling hot. I don’t buy that story, and apparently the bond market isn’t buying it either.

Next week’s economic calendar includes the ISM surveys of business activity in the manufacturing and services sector. What will be important to the outlook is what the surveys say about employment, export prospects and inventories. On Wednesday the Fed will release its Beige Book of regional economic reports. The next Fed FOMC meeting is June 17-18. Next Friday is the monthly jobs report; the unemployment rate, the headline number is at 6.3%, but that’s based on a participation rate at 62.8%. If the participation rate moves higher, look for the unemployment rate to jump.

Another big event next week, President Obama on Monday will unveil a plan to cut carbon pollution from power plants and promote cap-and-trade, undertaking the most significant action on climate change in American history. The proposed regulations could cut carbon pollution by as much as 25% from about 1,600 power plants in operation today. Power plants are the country's single biggest source of carbon pollution; responsible for up to 40% of the country's emissions.

The rules, which were drafted by the Environmental Protection Agency and are under review by the White House, are expected to put America on course to meet its international climate goal, and put US diplomats in a better position to leverage climate commitments from big polluters such as China and India. The plan is certain to result in political backlash with critics making doomsday claims about the costs of cutting carbon. Coal mining companies, power plant operators and others are already lining up for legal challenges to the executive action, claiming the approach oversteps the EPA’s authority.



Monday, June 24, 2013

Monday, June 24, 2013 - Hog Wild

Hog Wild
by Sinclair Noe

DOW – 139 = 14,659
SPX – 19 = 1573
NAS – 36 = 3320
10 YR YLD + .03 = 2.55%
OIL + 1.26 = 94.95
GOLD – 16.00 = 1283.60
SILV - .43 = 19.79

On Friday's show we had a call near the end of the hour and the caller posed a good question: “has the Fed started tapering?” The answer is technically “no”. But I had a chance to reflect over the weekend and I think what the Fed has done is started the process of gauging market reaction to an eventual exit from QE. It's like dipping a toe in the water.

Or as Richard Fisher, president of the Dallas Fed, told the Financial Times today, “Markets tend to test things. We haven’t forgotten what happened to the Bank of England [on Black Wednesday]. I don’t think anyone can break the Fed . . . But I do believe that big money does organize itself somewhat like feral hogs. If they detect a weakness or a bad scent, they’ll go after it.”

Fisher said the exit has not started but last week's hints by Fed Chairman Bernanke were part of a process to prepare the markets for the end of central bank support; or as Mr. Fisher put it: “I don't want to go from Wild Turkey to Cold Turkey overnight.”

The People's Bank of China seems to be taking the Cold Turkey approach; they are telling the country's largest banks to rein in risky loans and improve their balance sheets, a warning that sent a jolt through already unsettled equity markets. Last week, China experienced a bit of a credit crunch as short-term borrowing rates jumped; the overnight lending rate hit a record high of more than 13% and another measure of cash in the banking system , the 7-day repo rate peaked at 25%.

The official state media reported that the central bank was targeting the shadow banking system, saying: “It's not that there's no money. It's that the money is not in the right places.” And so the People's Bank of China said the banks must prudently manage liquidity risks that have resulted from rapid credit expansion. This seems to be a clear indication that the Chinese government has no plans to loosen policies or inject liquidity to bring down interest rates. The likely result is Chinese economic growth will slow this year, with most estimates ranging about 7.5% growth – only 7.5%.

The Federal Reserve expects the US economy to grow at a 2.6% pace this year; right now, the economy is growing at about a 2% clip. It will take some more time to see if the Fed's rosy outlook is justified; the Fed is typically bad at forecasts. If you don't get more job creation and higher incomes, there won't be a meaningful increase in consumer spending or economic growth.

It's hard to get blood out of a turnip.

The turnip is the American consumer. A new report from Bankrate says 76% of Americans are living paycheck to paycheck, with next to nothing in savings; 50% of those surveyed have less than a 3-month cushion of savings and 27% had no savings at all. And the savings rate has barely changed over the past 3 years. And a new poll from the Murdoch Street Journal finds 58% of Americans think the US is in a recession even though the recession officially ended 4 years ago.

The reality is that most of America is still living through a small “d” depression and the Fed's testing the waters or measuring the aggressive nature of the bond market feral hogs does nothing to get us out of the depression. Talk of taper does nothing to improve the employment picture, but then QE hasn't done much to help the employment picture. Unemployment is down, but employment is not up; in other words, we've seen a drop in the number of people looking for a job, not an increase in job availability. The US has 2.4 million fewer jobs today than when the recession began. Adjusting for population growth, it will take more than nine years at the current rate of hiring to return to pre-recession employment levels.

There is a durable belief that much of today’s unemployment is rooted in a skills gap, in which good jobs go unfilled for lack of qualified applicants. This is mostly a corporate fiction. A Labor Department report last week showed 3.8 million job openings in the United States in April — proof, to some, that there would be fewer unemployed if more people had a better education and better skills. But both academic research and a closer look at the numbers in the department’s Job Openings and Labor Turnover Survey show that unemployment has little to do with the quality of the applicant pool.

In a healthy economy, job openings are plentiful and unemployment is low. April’s tally of 3.8 million openings might sound like a lot, but it is still well below the prerecession average, in 2007, of 4.5 million openings a month. It is also far lower than the record high of 5.2 million openings in December 2000, when the survey was started near the peak of a long economic expansion.


Unemployment is also stubbornly high — 7.5 percent in April, or 11.7 million people, a ratio of 3.1 job seekers for every opening. No category has been spared: unemployed workers outnumber openings in all of the 17 major sectors covered by the survey. The biggest problem in the labor market is not a skills shortage; rather, it is a persistently weak economy where businesses do not have sufficient demand to justify adding employees.

 In addition, when there are many more applicants than jobs, employers tend to impose overexacting criteria and then wait for the perfect match. They also offer tightfisted pay packages. What employers describe as talent shortages are often failures to agree on salary.

If a business really needed workers, it would pay up. That is not happening, which calls into question the existence of a skills gap as well as the urgency on the part of employers to fill their openings. Research from the National Bureau of Economic Research found that “recruiting intensity” — that is, business efforts to fill job openings — has been low in this recovery. Employers may be posting openings, but they are not trying all that hard to fill them, say, by increasing job ads or offering better pay packages.

Corporate executives have valuable perspectives on the economy, but they also have an interest in promoting the notion of a skills gap. They want schools and, by extension, the government to take on more of the costs of training workers that used to be covered by companies as part of on-the-job employee development. They also want more immigration, both low and high skilled, because immigrants may be willing to work for less than their American counterparts.

So, we have a problem with the Fed not accomplishing its mandate of full employment; what about the mandate for price stability? Well, there is very little inflation. There is a near zero chance of domestically generated inflation while wages are falling, and contractionary fiscal policy is depressing real incomes, and banks are not lending, and corporations are failing to invest. Externally driven inflation is possible and we are seeing some inflation in asset prices as a consequence of QE, but the core trend is disinflation in developed countries.

What the taper talk has accomplished is to push rates higher. Two months ago, the benchmark interest rate on the 10-year Treasury Note was about 1.62%; today it hit 2.62%. Higher rates will surely mean a slower recovery than we would have had if the Fed had avoided taper talk.

Right now, the feral bond hogs are winning. This bloodbath represents a 62% increase in borrowing costs for the federal government. Meanwhile, the average going rate for a 30-year fixed-rate mortgage has also risen by a full percentage point, to about 4.4 percent.

Today, the Bank of International Settlements, which is basically the central bank of the global central banks published its annual report on the state of the global economy. And they included a chapter on “Fiscal sustainability”, concluding: "While progress has been made towards reducing fiscal deficits, many economies still need to increase their primary balances significantly to put their debt on safer, downward trajectories." The BIS does not explain how rising interest rates might lower debt; and that is a major problem; rising rates means higher debt, just as slow growth leads to higher debt.

Instead, the BIS explains in its annual report, just how bad the losses might be if rates rise: “losses on US Treasury securities alone will reach $1 trillion if average yields rise by 300 basis points, with even greater damage in a string of other countries. The loss could range from 15% to 35% in France, Italy, Japan, and the UK. Such an upward move can happen relatively fast.” So says the BIS with a reference to the 1994 bond crash.


Monetary stimulus comes and goes; the idea is to try and time it so that it leaves when the economy is strong and can better handle the loss of stimulus. That's not what we saw this past week. Instead, we saw the Fed testing the waters, looking to withdraw stimulus based upon the markets' reaction. And that is entirely the wrong reasoning.